YProductions





The Next Generation Virtual Museum October 24, 2004 11:30 PM

Virtual Museum (of Canada)
The Next Generation

Steve Dietz, Kati Geber, Howard Besser, and Ann Borda

Written for and published by the Canadian Heritage Information Network

The Idea of the Next Generation
Next generation" can mean many things, but generally it refers to something beyond incremental or evolutionary improvements. For instance, in the summer of 2003, at a symposium on the "post-digital library," Clifford Lynch, the head of the Coalition for Networked Information, asked how the field would spend $1 billion (if it had it). The intent of the strategy was to get people to think about what next generation of digital libraries might mean beyond improving this or that strategy, as important and critical as such pragmatic matters remain. He argued in his written remarks: "We should recognize the limitations of a research program focusing on digital libraries as we understand them today. This is likely to lead to mostly incremental rather than transformative progress . . .. Rather than considering how to re-design or recreate or enhance libraries we might usefully focus our attention on the human and social purposes and needs that libraries and allied memory institutions have been intended to address . . .. And we must be careful not to overly-emphasize the parts of this knowledge ecosystem that are familiar, that we are comfortable with intellectually, socially and economically, to the exclusion of the new, the unfamiliar, the disturbing, the confusing.1
By the same token, attempting to plan for transformative progress to a next generation can be unpredictable. In the mid-90s the United States' National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) began a program to design a next generation Reusable Vehicle Launcher-or space shuttle. It wanted to create a vehicle that would improve on the current technology by an order of magnitude in key areas.2 NASA's goals proved wildly unachievable, in part because there were too many variables that required breakthrough inventions.

Both Lynch's exhortations and NASA's experience are worth keeping in mind when considering the next generation Virtual Museum of Canada (VMC). On the one hand, it is important not to merely recreate museums online but to focus on the needs and desires of the user population, and to understand these within an information ecology that cannot be easily bounded as "museum." On the other hand, the Canadian Heritage Information Network (CHIN), and its members have equally real needs and desires that cannot be resolved solely through theorization. The VMC needs to address these as well.

This paper is designed to take a broad view of the potential for a virtual museum and from that to come up with some specific recommendations for VMC. Hopefully, we will not end up in outer space.


1. Clifford Lynch. "Reflections Towards the Development of a 'Post-DL' Research Agenda." Wave of the Future: NSF Post Digital Library Futures Workshop. June 15-17, 2003. http://www.sis.pitt.edu/~dlwkshop/paper_lynch.html. Accessed October 25, 2003.

Full text of paper at http://www.chin.gc.ca/English/Members/Next_Generation/

Contents
The Idea of the Next Generation
Executive Summary
Context
Audience
Interface
Content
Infrastructure and Architecture
Sustainability
Selected Bibliography